When I worked as a newspaper reporter, I received plenty of pitches from people who believed their news deserved attention. Some involved stories readers would genuinely care about. Others sounded more like advertisements with a headline attached.
That distinction still shapes how I think about public relations. A business may be proud of a new product, an award or an expansion, but a journalist's first responsibility is to the audience, not the organization making the announcement.
A useful pitch connects what matters to the business with what matters to the public.
Ask why someone outside the business should care
The first question isn't, “What do we want to announce?” It's, “Why would someone who doesn't work here find this useful, relevant or interesting?”
Consider a company opening another location. On its own, that may be a routine business development. But if the expansion brings a service to an underserved area, creates substantial local employment or changes access for customers, there's a more meaningful story to investigate.
The opening is still the event. The public impact gives it context.
That doesn't mean every announcement needs a dramatic consequence. It means we should be specific about the audience and honest about the significance.
Look for people, change and consequences
As a reporter, I covered business decisions, local government, growth and the people affected by them. The strongest stories rarely stopped with an institution's announcement. They explained what was changing and whom the change would affect.
Businesses can use that same lens when evaluating potential news. Is there a meaningful change? Does it affect workers, customers or the surrounding community? Is there a person whose experience makes the subject easier to understand?
A small business that has found an unusual way to address a local problem may offer a stronger story than a larger company making an ordinary announcement. Size alone doesn't determine relevance.
And human interest shouldn't be forced. Real people and verifiable details are more compelling than a manufactured feel-good angle.
Timing matters, but a calendar date isn't enough
Newsrooms work in the present. Announcements can become more relevant when they connect naturally to a current issue, community event or seasonal need.
In St. Augustine, for example, a credible business story might connect to the practical effects of tourism, neighborhood growth or changing local services. The connection has to be real. Adding “Nights of Lights” or another familiar phrase to an unrelated press release doesn't make the story more useful.
It's also worth considering when to share information. A reporter may need time to interview people, check facts, arrange photographs or visit a location. An invitation sent after an event has ended is less helpful than one that gives the newsroom a reasonable chance to cover it.
Bring the facts, not just the adjectives
Words such as “groundbreaking,” “innovative” and “industry-leading” appear in plenty of announcements. They tell the reader what the company thinks about itself. They don't explain what happened.
Specific, supportable information is much more useful. What changed? When did it happen? Where? How many people are affected? What is different from what existed before? Who can answer follow-up questions?
Good background material may include a straightforward explanation, names and titles, relevant numbers with context, accurate photographs and a contact who can respond promptly. If a claim can't be supported, I'd rather revise or remove it than make a reporter untangle it.
My years working on deadline taught me to value accuracy and accessibility. A clear answer delivered quickly is often more useful than a beautifully written statement that avoids the question.
Respect the difference between coverage and promotion
Earned media is not advertising. An editor decides whether a story runs, how it is framed and which details matter. A company can provide useful information and make knowledgeable people available, but it cannot responsibly promise the final coverage will read like its own marketing copy.
That lack of control is part of what distinguishes independent reporting from paid promotion. It also explains why pushing too hard for flattering language can undermine an otherwise productive relationship with a journalist.
A pitch should be concise, relevant to the outlet's audience and easy to evaluate. A generic release sent to every reporter in the region is rarely as useful as a thoughtful note to the person who actually covers that topic.
Not every good story needs a newspaper
Sometimes an announcement matters deeply to customers but isn't appropriate for a news outlet. That's fine. A new service, a staff milestone or a behind-the-scenes project may belong on the company's website, in an email newsletter or on its social channels.
Those are legitimate ways to communicate, and they give the business more control over the message. The important thing is to choose the channel based on the audience rather than treat media coverage as the only measure of a story's value.
Public relations and marketing work best together when each has a clear job. Newsworthiness helps determine whether to approach a journalist. Customer relevance helps determine what to communicate through the channels a business owns.
Think like a reporter before writing the pitch
Before drafting a press release, I would ask three questions: Is this new or meaningful? Can I explain why it matters to people beyond the business? Can I support the story with reliable facts and someone willing to answer questions?
If the answers are strong, there's a story worth developing. If they're not, there may still be a useful customer message — just not necessarily a media pitch.
The goal of good public relations isn't to make every business announcement sound like news. It's to recognize when a business has a story worth telling and make that story easy for others to understand.